Using the queuing model to evaluate and predict optimum outpatient pharmacy dispensing service in Lagos University Teaching Hospital
Article Sidebar
Main Article Content
Abstract
Background: Waiting times for health services arise because capacity does not match demand or capacity or demand is not well managed. Queuing theory is a powerful operational research tool which assists managers to make vital decisions capable of optimizing the performance of a health system facility, minimize operational costs and enhance the satisfaction of all interest groups.
Objective: To simulate the queuing model in the outpatient pharmacy in order to evaluate its performance and to develop necessary strategies for optimizing dispensing service.
Methods: The study was carried out at the Pharmacy Unit of Family Medicine / General Outpatient Department (GOPD) of Lagos University Teaching Hospital employing workflow analysis and time study. A sample size of 123 Ambulatory Patients was studied and data were collected daily over a period of four weeks. Data analysis was done using SPSS version 10.0 to determine waiting time for prescription validation and assessment, payment, filling, collection and counselling. The queuing system in Pharmacy was then simulated to determine measures such as Service Utilization Factor, Average Queuing Time in the queue and in the system, Average number of patients in queue and in the system, Waiting cost and Service cost all of which are necessary for evaluating service delivery in the outpatient setting.
Results: The study revealed a total patient waiting time of 79.24 min with the process component accounting for 7.9 ± 5.58 min (9.97%) and delay component responsible for 71.34 ± 66.93 min (90.03%). It was established that optimal service delivery would be achieved with two service points requiring six pharmacists in the pharmacy unit. This arrangement is expected to give an 88.1% reduction in mean total patient waiting time and 50% deduction in total cost when compared with existing system.
Conclusion: Significant reduction in waiting time can be made by facilitating service delivery at the prescription validation and assessment point. The excessive waiting time contributed by delay components underscored the need to employ more pharmacists to improve on the service system. Service efficiency would be optimized by increasing the number of service points to two in order to minimize the total operating costs.
Downloads
Article Details
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
References
Bailey NTJ (1952). A study of queues and appointment systems in hospital outpatient departments, with special reference to waiting
times. Journal of the Royal Statistical Society. Series B (Methodological). pp 185-199
Lindley DV (1952). The theory of queues with a single server. In: Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society. Cambridge Univ. Press.
Cayirli T and Veral E (2003). Outpatient scheduling in health care - A review of literature. Production and operations management 12(4): 519-549.
Patrick J and Puterman ML (2008). Reducing wait times through operations Research; Optimizing the use of surge capacity. Health Policy Feb; 3(3): 75-88
Moss G (1987). Hospital Pharmacy Staffing levels and outpatient waiting times. Pharmaceutical Journal 239:69-70.
Nosak RA and Wilson JP (2001). Queuing theory and customer satisfaction: A review of terminology, trends and applications to pharmacy practice. Hospital Pharmacy 36(3): 275-279.
Lin AC, Jang R, Sedani D et al (1996). Reengineering a Pharmacy work system and layout to facilitatepatient counseling. American Journal of Health System Pharmacy 53:1558-1564
Venuri S (1984). Simulated analysis of patient waiting time in an outpatient pharmacy. American Journal of Hospital Pharmacy 41:1127-1130
Helbig M, Helbig S, Kahla-Witsch HA and May A (2009). Quality Management: reduction of waiting time and efficiency, enhancement in an ENT - University outpatients department. BMC Health Services Research 9:21.
Afolabi MO and Erhun W O (2003). Patients' response to waiting time in an outpatient pharmacy in Nigeria. Tropical Journal of Pharmaceutical Research 2(2): 207-214.
Bahadori M, Mohammadnejhad SM, Ravangard R and Tejmourzadeh E (2014). Using Queuing theory and simulation model to optimize HospitalPharmacy Performance. Iran Red Crescent Medical Journal 16(3): e16807.
Soyemi OI and Erhun WO (2014). Patient response to waiting time at the outpatient pharmacy of the National Orthopaedic Hospital, Igbobi, Lagos. West African Journal of Pharmacy 25(1): 20-26.
Ndukwe HC, Omale S and Opanuga OO (2011). Reducing queues in a Nigerian Hospital Pharmacy. African Journal of Pharmacy and Pharmacology Vol 5(8): 1020 - 1026.
Jun J, Jacobson S and Swisher J (1999). Application of discrete event simulation in health care clinics: A survey. Journal of Operational Research Society 50(2): 109-123.
Hashimoto F and Bell S (1996). Improving outpatient clinic staffing and scheduling with computer
simulation. Journal of General Internal Medicine 11(3):182-184.
Swisher JR and Jacobson SH (2002). Evaluating the design of a family practice health care clinic using discrete - event simulation. Health Care Management Science 5(2): 75-88
Kembe MM, Onah ES and Iorkagh S (2012). A study of waiting and service costs of a multi-server queuing model in a specialist hospital. International Journal of Scientific and Technological Research 1(8): 19-23
Hillier FS and Lieberman GJ (2010). Introduction to operations research. 7th edition, McGraw Hill, New York, USA.
Nahar K, Islam MZ and Islam MM (2016). Cost effective decisions on service rate at a customer care centre with multi server Queuing Model. Journal of Modern Science and Technology 4(1): 144-153.
Harper WM and Lim HC (1982). Operational research 2nd Edition, Pitman Publishing Limited London UK pp. 45-53.
Daniel WW (1974). Biostatistics: A foundation for analysis in the Health Sciences. John Wiley & Sons Inc. 130-134.
Ndukwe HC, Tayo F and Sariem NC (2011). Factors influencing waiting time in outpatient pharmacy of Lagos University Teaching Hospital. International Research Journal of Pharmacy 2(10): 22-26.
Lin AC, Jang R, Lobas N, Hilton P, Ivey M and Nam B (1999). Identification of factors leading to excessive waiting time in an ambulatory pharmacy. Hospital Pharmacy 34:707-12.
Ackoff RL and Sasieni MW (1968). Fundamentals of Operation Research. John Wiley and Sons Inc. New York, USA pp. 248-274
Chowdhury MSR, Rahman MT and Kabir MR (2013). Solving of waiting lines models in the bank using queuing theory model in Islamic Bank, Bangladesh as a case study. International Organization of Scientific Research Journal of Business and Management Volume 10 (1): 22-29.